Skip to main content

Why? Sargasso Sea: A Poor Prequel

Wide Sargasso Sea

Book Review by Margaret

Jean Rhys

Rating: 5/10

Date read: 17 February to 2 April


    Wide Sargasso Sea is a 1966 novel written as a prequel to Charlotte Bronte’s ‘Jane Eyre’, which serves as a postcolonial and feminist perspective on Bertha’s backstory. The novel presents themes such as ‘Victorian paternalism, sexualised racism and the complex social and political history of the West Indies’ (British Library). 

The story is told from the alternating perspectives of Bertha, who is called Antoinette Cosway originally, and Rochester. It begins in Antoinette’s early childhood in her crumbling West Indian family estate and follows her life up until her imprisonment in Thornfield Hall. The story focuses on Antoinette’s relationships with those around her, particularly her mother, her maid Christophine and Rochester himself. The narrative is incredibly sensual and highly charged with anger, fear, bitterness, madness and erotica. This is enhanced by the exotic setting and the reader’s knowledge that all does not turn out well for Antoinette in the end.

I chose to read this book due to my AS Level studies in ‘Jane Eyre’, as it provides a wealth of useful contextual information in understanding and analysing Bronte’s original novel. However, I found the story itself very flat. The writing style was so disconnected and obscure that it was nearly impossible to engage with the characters or events. It is true that this writing style accurately and cleverly reflects the state of Antoinette’s troubled mind and her erratic behaviour, but I found it so incomprehensible as to actually act as a barrier between the reader and any sympathy for Antoinette. Thus, although the novel presents a perfectly valid case for Antoinette (Bertha), in humanising her and explaining her horrific state in ‘Jane Eyre’, it is completely sabotaged by the incoherent narrative.

It is to be confessed on my part that I am not of the Gilbert and Gubarian tribe in my opinion on Bertha and Rochester’s relationship in ‘Jane Eyre’. I cannot believe that Bertha’s madness was purely a result of ‘racism’ and ‘the patriarchy’– even ‘Wide Sargasso Sea’ shows her generational and innate tendency towards mentally and emotionally unbalanced behaviour, not to mention her incredibly traumatic childhood. Thus, I am biased in Rochester’s favour in this respect (though many of his actions are inexcusable, though not unforgivable). I find it difficult to take Rhys’ interpretation of Bertha in ‘Jane Eyre’ very seriously, especially when it is presented in such an incongruous and outlandish manner. 

While I agree that the novel succeeded in leaving upon the reader an impression of the great injustice of Antoinette’s life, and the great injustice of Rochester’s treatment of her, I did not feel that it was sufficiently well-written or reasoned out to be considered impactful. Thus, my low rating– yet I must allow for the sublime use of the story’s setting to create the intensely sensual atmosphere which colours the story, a perfect complement to the plot.

Wide Sargasso Sea (1993) - IMDb

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

'Closed Like Confessionals': Larkin on Mortality in 'Ambulances'

  Explore how Larkin presents mortality in ‘Ambulances’ By Margaret   Larkin’s poem ‘Ambulances’ presents themes of mortality and the meaning of life through death. The grim tone of the poem is set in the first line when Larkin describes ambulances as ‘Closed like confessionals’. This religious element seems very bleak in this context, giving an impression of intimacy and truth, both things which are present at the moment of a person’s death. This immediate yet subtle introduction of the theme of mortality chills the atmosphere of the poem, which uses the image of an ambulance to embody the reality of mortality.          Inevitable and unpredictable reminders of our mortality are also emphasised in this poem, using the ambulance metaphor. In the first stanza, Larkin states that ‘All streets in time are visited’ by the ambulance, and that they could stop at ‘any kerb’, presenting mortality as an ominous, lingering presence which is p...
Post a Comment
Read more

'What Will Survive of Us is Love': Larkin's 'An Arundel Tomb'

Explore how Larkin depicts love in this poem.   By Margaret Larkin begins the poem, ‘An Arundel Tomb’, by describing a 14 th  century tomb in Chichester Cathedral, for which the poem is named: ‘Side by side their faces blurred, /The earl and countess lie in stone’. Immediately, the fact that the stone reproductions of this dead husband and wife are lying ‘Side by side’ conveys an image of tragic romance, of undying love. Yet Larkin is neutral, simply describing the monument, without commenting on its meaning.             In the second stanza, Larkin focuses on the most interesting aspect of the ‘Arundel Tomb’: ‘One sees, with a sharp tender shock, /His hand withdrawn, holding her hand.’ This sweet detail seems almost misplaced in the cynical, nihilistic world of Larkin’s poetry. His use of the phrase ‘sharp tender shock’ perfectly relates the surprise with which a visitor to the Cathedral would notice such a detail. L...
Post a Comment
Read more

To Atone or Not To Atone? McEwan's Two-Sided Tale

Atonement Book review by Margaret Ian McEwan Rating: 8/10 Date read: 8 June to 11 June Atonement is a 2001 British metafiction novel which takes place in three settings: 1935 England, Second World War England and France, and 1999 England. It follows the story of Briony Tallis, a thirteen-year-old, upper-class girl whose innocent mistake one summer night ruins the lives of her elder sister, Cecelia, and Cecelia’s childhood friend and lover, Robbie Turner. Briony spends the rest of her life trying to atone for her mistake, as the effects of it spread throughout her family. Atonement is centred around themes such as the power of storytelling, the nature of perspective, regret and guilt, and childhood versus adulthood (Sparknotes).  In short, I was enthralled by the first half and utterly bored by the second. I thought the writing was excellent; the setting was richly vivid, the characters deep and unique, and the story (at least the first part) absolutely gripping. Yet I hate war...
Post a Comment
Read more