To Atone or Not To Atone? McEwan's Two-Sided Tale

Atonement

Book review by Margaret

Ian McEwan

Rating: 8/10

Date read: 8 June to 11 June

Atonement is a 2001 British metafiction novel which takes place in three settings: 1935 England, Second World War England and France, and 1999 England. It follows the story of Briony Tallis, a thirteen-year-old, upper-class girl whose innocent mistake one summer night ruins the lives of her elder sister, Cecelia, and Cecelia’s childhood friend and lover, Robbie Turner. Briony spends the rest of her life trying to atone for her mistake, as the effects of it spread throughout her family. Atonement is centred around themes such as the power of storytelling, the nature of perspective, regret and guilt, and childhood versus adulthood (Sparknotes).

In short, I was enthralled by the first half and utterly bored by the second. I thought the writing was excellent; the setting was richly vivid, the characters deep and unique, and the story (at least the first part) absolutely gripping. Yet I hate war stories, and Atonement, though disguised, turned into just that. Watching Robbie crawl through war-torn France was a poor sequel to the compelling mystery and frustration of Part One. The book did redeem itself slightly towards the end, with a bittersweet and sentimental resolution which I thought particularly clever.

I certainly enjoyed the novel, hence its high rating, but I felt that the narrative would have benefitted from a greater focus on the original setting and story. It seemed that the disconnection between parts of the narrative slowed the story down and created a certain apathy in the reader. Nevertheless, I thought that the portrayal of the characters, particularly Briony, Cecelia and Robbie, was artfully done and the setting of Part One was a feast of imagery. I would definitely recommend this book as a recreational read.

Atonement | Rotten Tomatoes

Comments

The Love and Lies of Mr Rochester

How far do you agree with the statement ‘Jane is subjected to unacceptable levels of manipulation and deceit at the hands of Mr. Rochester’? By Margaret It is certainly true that Mr. Rochester subjects Jane to extreme and nearly intolerable levels of manipulation throughout Charlotte Brontë’s 1847 novel Jane Eyre . Indeed, it is one of the central themes of the book, and almost none of the major events of the story would have taken place if Rochester had not deceived Jane regarding a certain skeleton-in-the-closet, or in this case, wife-in-the-attic. However, the question remains: are Rochester’s attempts to manipulate and deceive Jane in any way acceptable? The first and most notable of instance of Rochester’s deceit and manipulation towards Jane is when he brings Blanche Ingram to Thornfield. From the first mention of Miss Ingram, she is described as “‘beautiful’, ‘accomplished’” and “‘graceful’”. Mr. Roche...

The Odyssey: Is Penelope Perfect?

To what extent do you agree that Penelope is portrayed as completely without fault in The Odyssey ? By Margaret The character of Penelope in The Odyssey is portrayed as a woman of the highest and purest moral order. Penelope is frequently commended by other characters for her ‘loyalty’ to Odysseus and described throughout the narrative as ‘prudent’ and ‘flawless.’ Thus, it is clear that Homer presents Penelope as completely without fault in The Odyssey and that his original audience would have received her as such. However, the questions persist as to whether Penelope possesses any implicit faults which remain unmentioned simply for narrative purposes, and whether Penelope’s apparent flawlessness is also timeless. Penelope’s character in her first appearance in The Odyssey could easily be considered without fault. Homer describes her as ‘gracious’, entering the room with her ‘waiting-women’ and standing with her ‘shining veil ac...

Blood or Bodies: Which Part of The Odyssey is Most Horrific?

Which part of Odysseus’ journey do you feel is the most horrifying? By Margaret Odysseus’ journey from Troy to his home in Ithaca is full of dramatic, dangerous and exhilarating events. Many of these events involve gruesome and appalling acts of violence and result in the deaths of some of Odysseus’ companions, leaving the survivors in great distress. There are three main events in ‘The Odyssey’ which could be considered the most horrific: Odysseus’ encounter with Laestrygonians (from which Passage B is taken) , Odysseus’ encounter with the monster Scylla, or Odysseus’ encounter with ‘the tribes of the dead’ . In Passage B, an exploration party sent from Odysseus’ crew is ‘confronted by Antiphates’ wife’, a giant , terrifying woman who immediately summons her husband, ‘the famous Antiphates’ , upon meeting the men. Antiphates ‘promptly [makes] his murderous intentions clear ’ and snatches and eats one of them men. The other men flee back to the ship ...

A Wife Now Living

Search This Blog